Reflection Group “Monopoly on the use of force 2.0?”

Is there a need for new peace and ­security rules in the 21st century?

Volker Böge

Think Piece No. 6: Case Study: Security Provision in Bougainville

After a protracted violent conflict, a home-grown state based on a hybrid political order is emerging on the Pacific island of Bougainville in Papua New Guinea. Markedly different from the Weberian notion of statehood, peace, order and security are maintained through the combined efforts of state, customary actors and civil society. Even though the capacity to implement and enforce the »rule of (state) law« is lacking in Bougainville, post-conflict peacebuilding was successful and political order and security have been established on the basis of positive mutual accommodation of introduced state and local customary institutions.

Bild: Cover der Publikation; Bild: FES

Summary

  • After a protracted violent conflict, the Pacific island of Bougainville in Papua New Guinea has undergone a comprehensive and to date relatively successful process of post-conflict peacebuilding and is currently in the process of state formation.
  • A home-grown state based on a hybrid political order is emerging. State formation is focused on reconciling institutions of the state with non-state customary community governance mechanisms and cultural norms.
  • Peace, order and security are maintained through the combined efforts of state, customary actors and civil society. A core dimension of statehood is thus organized in a way that differs markedly from the Western Weberian notion of statehood.
  • What is generally seen as a sine qua non of statehood, namely the capacity to implement and enforce the »rule of (state) law,«is lacking in Bougainville, due to the weakness of the police, the judiciary and other state institutions. This »deficiency,«however, has not hindered post-conflict peacebuilding, nor has it been detrimental to the establishment of political order and security. Rather, order and security are based on the positive mutual accommodation of introduced state and local customary institutions.

Böge, Volker

Case study: Security provision in Bougainville

Berlin, 2015

Publikation herunterladen (200 KB, PDF-File)


Latest Issues

  • Mely Caballero-Anthony, Frieden und Sicherheit | Publikation

    Think Piece 22: Security in Times of Uncertainty in Asia

    Asias security outlook still appears to be laden with uncertainties. From the changing dynamics in the balance of power, an emboldened North Korea and…

    weitere Informationen

  • Ann L. Phillips, Frieden und Sicherheit | Publikation

    Think Piece 21: Providing Security in Times of Uncertainty

    The final report, distills the findings of a two-year effort by more than 20 international experts to find answers on how to overcome rising…

    weitere Informationen

  • Jaïr van der Lijn, Publikation

    Think Piece 20: The future of the monopoly on the legitimate use of force - Four alternative global futures

    The paper presents four alternative global futures for the monopoly on the legitimate use of force that aim to allow policy makers to embrace…

    weitere Informationen

Dep. Global Policy and Development

more

Project Coordinator:
Bodo Schulze

030 / 269 35-7409

bodo.schulze(at)fes.de

nach oben