Global Policy and Development

19.12.2017

“My Country First” Rhetoric: Like Water off a Duck's Back to the UN

A reformed Security Council is key to credible international crisis management, so the 2017 FES Tiergarten Conference concludes.

Image: Public Panel of Konstantin Boerner

Image: Tom Perriello of Konstantin Börner

Image: Pascal Boniface of Konstantin Boerner

Image: Richard Gowan of Konstantin Boerner

Image: Rouzbeh Parsi of Konstantin Boerner

Trump, Putin, Abe, Modi, Duterte, Erdoğan: The list of “strong statesmen” could be continued further – also in view of Central Europe and South America. Worldwide, populists and strictly authoritarian movements are gaining followers. By threatening to withdraw from multilateral organizations or denying their legitimacy, their “Our Nation First”attitude also puts pressure on international peace and security order.

So can international multilateralism, and with it human rights, rule of law and multilateral crisis management, be said to be in a veritable crisis? This was the key question discussed by politicians and scientists from Brazil, China, Germany, France,Great Britain and Russia at the 2017 Tiergarten Conference, the annual FES meeting on foreign and security policy. The answer: A resounding yes and no.

In connection with the UN, participants stated that populist rulers too use the Security Council as global crisis managers, but also noted that at the same time, the Council's “old” problems still endure.
Even outspoken UN critics like Donald Trump utilize the UN Security Council in order to handle the North Korea nuclear crisis. Similarly, Syria's accession to the Chemical Weapons Convention would have been impossible without the UN. Consequently, the UN system can be said to work in regard to security crises with global dimensions, so UN-expert Richard Gowan from the European Center for Foreign Relations. But when the crises do not affect the Security Council Members' geostrategic interests, the UN fail on a regular basis, with devastating consequences for the people in countries like Myanmar, South Sudan or Yemen.

Therefore, the primary threat to the UN is not the increasing strength of authoritarian forces. Rather, both the ability to act and the credibility of the UN in general are in danger, due to the fact that the Security Council reform, which has been discussed for decades, has still not happened until today.
Against this background, right-wing rhetorical attacks against international organizations cannot be simply dismissed per se, so the US politician Tom Perriello. For too long, technocratic apparatuses – including UN and EU organizations – were able to evade urgent reforms that could lead to more transparency, effectivity and accountability. Accordingly, answering populist politicians' attacks with a blanket reference to “liberal world order” is not enough.

Instead, Perriello emphasized, multilateral organizations must contribute to a better life for people. Populations must experience in a concrete way that it pays off to relinquish a piece of sovereignty to the international community. This is also true in regard to fears of a loss of control and direction. Only this will lead to a higher acceptance of international organizations and at the same time invalidate critics' arguments.

For further information, please visit the homepage of the Tiergartenkonferenz.

Countries / regions: Weltweit

Department/Section: Globale Politik und Entwicklung


  • Contact

    Global Policy and Development

    Head of Department

    Jochen Steinhilber

    Contact

    Julia Kühne, Assistant to the Head of Department

    Hiroshimastraße 28
    10785 Berlin

    030/269 35-7510

    Julia.Kuehne(at)fes.de

    Specific Requests

    Please refer to Team & Contact for a list of our experts on specific topics

  • Expertise

    The Global Policy and Development Department deals with the following range of topics:

    • democracy-building
    • development policy
    • peace and security, disarmament
    • gender justice
    • global economy, taxes and trade policy
    • international energy and climate change policy
    • international trade union policy
    • migration and development
    • social justice
    • business and human rights

    We look forward to exchanging ideas with you. You can find your contact persons here.

Ansprechpartner

Konstantin Bärwaldt
Konstantin Bärwaldt
+49 30 269 35-7501

Similar posts

Remains of weapons were found at the site of an air attack

Read more

Remains of weapons were found at the site of an air attack

Read more

A call to arms 2.0

Read more
nach oben